Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Action item for next week to issue a CFP

Licensing

Botimer

Armintor and Botimer discussed this earlier on Slack

Looking into details for ASF...operating and treating documentation of copyright

Operate similarly to how Samvera does

CLA's was borrowed heavily with a preamble specific to Samvera

We do not assign copyright

Authors to code retain copyright

Group retains the composite

Combination itself is a work in its own right

ASF: One copyright statement for derivative work (combined thing)

There is an open question...can we make a copyright statement for the collective work

There are examples would lead us to believe that "Samvera Community" would be okay with a separate list of authors

There is a challenge with existing practices...commit log uses an e-mail address

Might resolve cleanly in terms of GitHub...good tracking for CLAs and their employers

Contributions are work-for-hire

But, still not clear

There are two courses

Check with Michael Klein as product owner who is in the copyright statement for MIT on BE

Change to ASF

Theoretically could change the licenses without including MIT, but best to include the MIT license and specify that this exclusively covers previous releases

Ensure that this is consistent with other Gems in Samvera

Other action

Concise summary of what we are seeing...and work we are seeing to get to a simple practice towards evaluating projects as following guidelines

Ensuring that file contents (e. g. the top portion of a notice document is the same line)

List of institutions who want specific adjustments for the notice file (e. g. Trustees of...)

This way the guidelines are simple, can be readily checked

Provide a single file where additional copyright holders are specified

Pendragon:

How are we all over the board now?

Botimer:

Nobody has challenged the current copyright statement

Headers in certain files might still have copyright ownership information (e. g. jQuery plugin files with this information)

Would like to have one formula...for structuring this content and placing it within specific files

We should have one descriptive file...without consulting an external source (e. g. the git history)

Notes that the tarball won't have that

Get BE over to Apache license

Summarize the inconsistency, make a proposal for better consistency to vet amongst ourselves and take to the Partners