Digital Commons Feature Matrix

Inspired by https://gavialib.com/2017/08/what-was-bepress/, and the Friday, August 11 Samvera Partner call.

Digital Commons Feature	Hyku	Hyrax	Hyrax with Analytics and Collection Extensions	Fulcrum	figshare for Institutions	DSpace	Islandora
Expert Gallery Suite (integration)					NA		Possible. Not out of the box. Drupal community can be leveraged for Gallery, Slide Show, or Exhibit features.
Author profiles ("Selected Works")					NA		Yes. Scholar objects are described in MADS. Example: http://islandscholar.ca/islandora/object/ir%253Aabdelaziz
Journal publishing					NA		Possible. No content type for Journals; however, a Journal could be organized or represented by the Collection Content Model. There is support for individual journal articles (Citation cModel)
Impact & analytics ("the map")			In progress - with Analytics Working Group			Possible through add-on: https://www.atmire.com/modules/content-usage-analysis-for-dspace	Islandora Google Analytics and Islandora Altmetrics modules are available out of the box. There isn't an analytics map feature.
Impact & analytics (email notifications)			In progress - with Analytics Working Group	On roadmap for 2018.	Metrics on shares, views, downloads and citations on all research objects View metrics at an object, researcher, department or institutional level View workflow statuses, quota thresholds and usage statistics Integrate statistics into your RIMS or CRIS	Possible through add-on: https://www.atmire.com/modules/content-usage-analysis-for-dspace	Possible. Drupal Rules module can be leveraged to create email notifications triggered by specific hooks.
Improved SEO (GScholar?)							Yes. Google Scholar tags are added to a citation object's page to be crawled by GoogleBots. Tags are also recognized by Zotero. When using a default Dublin Core display, Schema. org specific tags are added to metadata fields.
ETD workflow		Available via customizable workflows	Available via customizable workflows			Yes, via customizable workflows	Yes. Islandora Scholar suite of modules provides content model support for thesis/dissertations and citations. Various batch ingest options via DOI, PMID, EndNote, RDF, etc.
Conferences & events						Yes, via collections, but only to host content.	No.
Open Educational Resources/Books							No.
"Complex collections"		Collection Extensions work allow for complex collections	Collection Extensions work allow for complex collections		ability to group content by "department"	Yes. Collections with sub collections.	Yes. Collections can have sub-collections. Objects can be members of more than one collection.
Exhibit-like presentation							Possible. Not out of the box. Drupal community can be leveraged for Exhibit features. Or possible to integrate will external applications such as Omeka.
"Customizable metadata"					Yes, you are able to add custom metadata fields at an institutional or department level.	Yes. Modified Qualified Dublin Core primarily. I/O functionality with MODS and MARC	Yes. Islandora XML Forms and Form Builder can support any XML-based schema. A knowledge of xpath is needed to modify forms.
"Recommended citations"					yes	No.	No.
"Design and branding customization"	Customizable design, branding, and content blocks	Customizable design, branding, and content blocks	Customizable design, branding, and content blocks	Designed for white-label honsting, with custom color scheme, fonts, logos, and content blocks.	Yes, there are elements of the figshare portal you can tailor to your institution's brand.	Yes. By community and collection	Yes. Drupal is the front end of Islandora and is infinitely customizable.
Digital Commons Network		NA - though possible connectivity via other services (e.g. SHARE)	NA - though possible connectivity via other services (e.g. SHARE)		figshare.com	No.However, repository can be harvested by aggregators through via OAI	No. However, repository can be harvested by aggregators through the Islandora OAI module to promote discovery of repository assets.
DOI integration				Accepts DOIs as metadata. Batch registration of DOIs to CrossRef on roadmap for 2018.	yes	No. DOI can be added as metadata.	Yes. DOI can be added to a metadata entry/ editing form as an identifier field. See Islandora XML Form builder. There is a DOI batch ingest module that allows an user to upload a txt file of comma separated DOIs or compile a list of DOIs in a GUI for ingest. Some community members have build custom workflows that mint DOIs when a research object is published or embargoed.
ORCID integration						No.	Limited. ORCID can be added to a metadata entry/ editing form as an identifier field. See Islandora XML Form builder.
Hosted Option	H yku Direct	NA	NA	Yes	figshare.com	dspacedirect.org	Yes. Community service providers offer hosted options. Or users can stand it up on a cloud provider themselves.