Metadata Call 2026-05-26

Samvera Community Wiki


Metadata Call 2026-05-26

Time: 2:00pm-3:00pm Eastern / 1-2 pm Central / 11 am-12 pm Pacific

Community Notes: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1G8wmi9R3q1uHatQLa3JfmlVr1-laTO5vgYzUZz-B7QU/edit?tab=t.0

 

2026-05-26

Moderator(s): Annamarie Klose

Notetaker: Emma Beck

Attendees: 

  • Heather Greer Klein, Samvera

  • Annamarie Klose, Ohio State University

  • Rachel Howard, University of Louisville

  • Julie Hardesty, Indiana University

  • Nic Don Stanton-Roark, PALNI

  • Emma Beck, University of Louisville - she/her

  • Dolsy Smith, GWU

  • Jessica McMillen, West Virginia University

  • Benjamin Riesenberg (they/them), U. of Oregon

  • Morgan McKeehan (she/her/hers), Oregon State University Libraries & Press

  • Rachel Jacobson (she/her/hers), Georgetown University

  • Margaret Kibi, UC Santa Barbara

Agenda: 

  • Samvera updates

  • Repository for YAML file examples and related documentation (Hyrax issue 7144) - Morgan McKeehan

  • Hierarchical metadata (see #metadata Slack discussion)

    • Related discussion point: If ORCID API support was added to Hyrax and Hyku, a metadata consideration would be how to support ORCID metadata, e.g., ORCID ids, in those platforms. UNC’s Carolina Digital Repository, for instance, has created a custom way of supporting ORCID information.

    • For example - in Fedora if you enter authors, it doesn’t always order them. 

    • Ordering is part of what people are after here – https://github.com/gwu-libraries/scholarspace-5-test/issues/77

    • It is very possible to do nested/hierarchical metadata in the backend, but it is very hard to make an edit form for it in the UI. If you only care about automated processes/bulk edit, it is feasible with Valkyrie.

    • Working group years ago tried to offer up options and no one could agree

    • Would ordering the authors meet 95% of the use cases? Creator/contributor would likely be the priority

    • Would just ordering things fix this?

    • (possible challenge?) bc in Fedora: 

      • the hashed URI’s are not fully separate objects in Fedora, though Fedora does display them as “Related resources” when looking at the main (un-hashed) URIs.

    • An ideal scenario would be: Ordering would carry over to an associated field

    • From RDF background - able to look back at predicates, more transparent

    • considerations for representing Roles and persons

      • for example: multiple roles for one person

    • example use case: a folklorist went around a state collecting folk songs 100 years ago:

    • Takeaways: 

      • “hierarchical metadata” means different things to diff folks/in diff contexts. Bringing up this question demonstrates that we’re all coming to it with diff use cases. Very helpful to discuss it as a group, to make all these variations explicit and start to clarify them. 

      • would like to gather & document more use cases

      • Now that we have more backend options than just Fedora - has this opened up possibilities for how we could approach this? Maybe this is a good time to revisit this issue for this reason. 

      • Is there a “design page” for this issue? 

        • Nick/Notch8 will check, will create if not yet exists. Into this area in Hyku confluence “Proposed Features and Needs”: Proposed Features and Needs

        •  

    • In UCSD comet: [check rolling notes for screenshot]

  • Open discussion

    • Oregon digital question about alt-text. Morgan would love examples. Slack or email morgan.mckeehan@oregonstate.edu 

      • The field is in Hyku and being added to Hyrax. More challenging for compound objects. UofL has some development work 

      • Lots of interest in this, will be added to the agenda for next month