Page Comparison

...

Moderator: Eben English

Notetaker: TBD (Etherpad: https://etherpad.wikimedia.org/p/MODS_and_RDF_Call__2018-08-06)

Attendees:

• your name here!

...

1. Feedback Form Responses (no new entries as of 8/1)
   
   1. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DRAzr3ExEAjK2RUs63gxcymoDwprQjVRPDsU_3dDGVU/edit?usp=sharing
      
      
2. Email Responses (no new entries as of 8/1)
   
   1. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/146uvvKt5ZVvWjm9WV28fWHgCP8fYQ_JXkc5GcMv98Wc/edit?usp=sharing
      
      
3. New Comments on Recommendations document
   1. General comments
      1. Concerns about number of namespaces utilized
      2. Comment regarding MODS to BIBFRAME conversion
   2. Simple Mapping
      1. mods:title 
         1. language tags; 
         2. clarifications regarding simple vs. minted scenarios
         3. question regarding nameTitleGroup attribute mapping (not in our examples)
      2. mods:name
         1. comment that relators requires a URI , which (we confirmed with LC that it can accept literals)
         2. comments about use of contributor instead of creator in cases of a name entry with an unspecified role 
      3. mods:genre
         1. Comment suggesting we have a typo in the syntax for one example
      4. mods:originInfo
         1. comments regarding datatypes, EDTF usage
         2. request for dateOther mapping/examples
      5. mods:physicalDescription
         1. comments regarding mimetype vs. format and suggestions for alternatives
         2. comments regarding 1:1 principle
      6. mods:subject
         1. comment regarding dce:coverage
         2. comment regarding syntax (last example)
      7. mods:relatedItem
         1. comment regarding minting separate objects
         2. comments regarding multiple "partOf" oriented predicates (should we clarify some of the Samvera implementation constraints regarding re-using predicates within a model?) 
         3. comments regarding seriesStatement
         4. comment regarding DOI syntax
      8. mods:identifier
         1. comment regarding use of schema:url
         2. comment regarding identifier:local and repository context
      9. mods:location
         1. comment regarding edm domain/range
      10. mods:accessCondition
          1. comment regarding rightsHolder example
          2. comment regarding example 4 
      11. mods:extension
          1. comment regarding extension ontologies
      12. mods:recordInfo
          1. comments regarding administrative domain in example 1 (description of metadata)
   3. Complex Option
      1. mods:titleInfo
         1. multiple comments for Example 1 (BIBFRAME, primary, and nonSort)
         2. comments for Example 3 (loss of granularity, skosxl usage, primary/preferred context, repository implementation)
         3. comments for Example 6: alternative supplied title
      2. mods:name
         1. comment regarding nameOrder predicate alternative
         2. comments for example 1: namePart types, RWOs (and a more broad comment about RWOs throughout the mapping)
         3. comment for example 10: use of creator role
         (to be added from document review)
         1. comment for example 11: inappropriate data shown for namePart
      3. mods:language
         1. comment regarding objectPart attribute (subtitles, etc.)
      4. mods:targetAudience
         1. comment for example 1: use of rdfs:label
      5. mods:subject
         1. general comment regarding use of MADS/RDF for subject heading part parsing
         2. comment regarding example 3: LCSH subdivisions
         3. comment for example 7: multiple subject elements with subdivisions
         4. comments for example 10: date in namePart; typos in example (original MODS sample vs. resulting RDF example's date values)
         5. comments for example 12: geographic coordinates
      6. mods:relatedItem
         1. General comment regarding establishing separate entities with their own URIs for all related item scenarios
      7. mods:location
         1. comments regarding predicates and BIBFRAME equivalents
      8. mods:recordInfo
         1. comment for example 1: datatype suggestion
            
            
4. BIBO predicates
   1. Status of project: confirm group email discussions
   2. Replacements for:
      1. bibo:issue; bibo:edition; bibo:volume
      2. bibo:presentedAt: discuss alternatives needed for complex/minted option based on group email discussion (requires a URI)
         
         
5. Proposal for Samvera Connect session
   1. Update on submission
      
      
6. Next meeting:
   1. TBD

...